On November 22, 2024, 20-year-old Cody DaShon Reed died in a car crash in Tulsa.
He left behind parents, grandparents, five siblings, and a family struggling with a loss no criminal sentence could undo. Weeks after his death, his relatives were raising money online to purchase a headstone. The cost was $4,900, and they needed a down payment before the monument could be made.[1]
There is something especially difficult about that detail when viewed alongside what happened in the criminal case that followed.
The man responsible for Reed's death would eventually receive a 20-year prison sentence.
The man responsible for Reed's death would eventually receive a 20-year prison sentence.
He would not be required to serve a single day of it.
The Crash
According to reporting by Fox23, Jerrion Dawyne White was driving approximately 112 miles per hour when the crash occurred. The reporting also described alcohol and marijuana in his system.[2]
The criminal case proceeded on charges that included first-degree manslaughter during the commission of a misdemeanor and driving under the influence of drugs and alcohol.
The criminal case proceeded on charges that included first-degree manslaughter during the commission of a misdemeanor and driving under the influence of drugs and alcohol.
White later acknowledged responsibility in his guilty plea. In the factual basis recorded in his plea paperwork, he admitted that his reckless driving caused Reed's death.[3]
The plea documents also reflected a blood alcohol concentration of approximately .06. That concentration was below the standard .08 threshold for adult DUI, but White was under 21, and the DUI charge was ultimately amended to an underage offense.[3]
The speed reported in news coverage and the alcohol findings matter. They are circumstances relevant to understanding the conduct that produced a fatal crash. They should not, however, be confused with a complete reconstruction of the collision or a finding that each reported detail was independently established at sentencing.
What is established by the criminal conviction is that White pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter in the case arising from Reed's death.
What is established by the criminal conviction is that White pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter in the case arising from Reed's death.
Twenty Years. All Suspended.
On May 18, 2026, White appeared before Tulsa County District Judge Michelle Keely. He was represented by private defense attorney Ben Fu. Assistant District Attorney Ashley Thompson appeared for the State.[4]
White entered guilty pleas, which the court accepted.
On the manslaughter count, the judge imposed a sentence of 20 years in the Oklahoma Department of Corrections. The signed judgment described the prison term as subject to Oklahoma's 85-percent sentencing provision.[5]
On the manslaughter count, the judge imposed a sentence of 20 years in the Oklahoma Department of Corrections. The signed judgment described the prison term as subject to Oklahoma's 85-percent sentencing provision.[5]
But the judgment contained another critical provision:
The entire term of imprisonment was suspended.
White also received a one-year sentence on the amended DUI count and a 90-day sentence on a third count. Both were suspended, and all counts were ordered to run concurrently.[4]
Instead of entering prison, White was placed under Department of Corrections probation supervision. His conditions included alcohol and drug education, follow-up sessions, a victim impact program, and restrictions on substance use.[4]
A suspended sentence is not an acquittal or an absence of legal consequences. White stands convicted of a felony. A violation of probation may expose him to revocation proceedings and potential imprisonment.[6]
But there is a profound difference between a sentence pronounced in a courtroom and a sentence a defendant is actually required to serve.
For the death of Cody Reed, White received no immediate incarceration.
The Prosecutor's Agreement
The Prosecutor's Agreement
This was not simply a case in which a judge imposed an unexpectedly lenient sentence over the prosecution's objection.
The plea paperwork reviewed in our original investigation contained a recommendation for a 20-year suspended sentence. A prosecutor-signed certification acknowledged the sentencing recommendation recorded in the paperwork.[7]
That distinction is important.
Judges possess sentencing discretion, subject to the law. Prosecutors possess a different kind of discretion: the authority to decide what charges to pursue, whether to negotiate a guilty plea, and what punishment the State will recommend.
Here, the court accepted a disposition that the prosecution had agreed to recommend.
The available plea and sentencing documents do not explain why the State agreed to suspend the entirety of the manslaughter sentence.
They do not disclose whether evidentiary concerns influenced the agreement, what mitigating circumstances were presented, or whether Reed's family supported the proposed punishment.
The plea paperwork identified no prior felony convictions for White, a factor potentially relevant to sentencing. But that fact alone does not explain the particular decision to recommend no initial incarceration.[3]
The plea paperwork identified no prior felony convictions for White, a factor potentially relevant to sentencing. But that fact alone does not explain the particular decision to recommend no initial incarceration.[3]
There may be additional explanations in a presentence investigation, discussions with the victim's family, or the sentencing hearing transcript. Those materials were not part of the documents available for this report.
The distinction matters: the absence of an explanation in the documents examined is not evidence of improper conduct.

Photo: Colleen McCarty · source
It is, however, a reason to ask questions.
What Does the Law Require?
What Does the Law Require?
First-degree manslaughter is a serious felony under Oklahoma law. It includes certain unlawful killings committed without an intent to cause death while the defendant is engaged in a misdemeanor.[8]
It is also included among offenses covered by Oklahoma's 85-percent sentencing statute, which generally restricts parole eligibility when an offender is serving a term of imprisonment.[9]
That provision does not, by itself, establish that the court lacked authority to suspend White's sentence. Oklahoma law separately provides sentencing courts with authority to suspend execution of a sentence, subject to applicable statutory restrictions.[6]
The issue raised by White's case is therefore not simply whether a 20-year suspended sentence was legally possible.
The issue raised by White's case is therefore not simply whether a 20-year suspended sentence was legally possible.
The more important question is why it was considered appropriate.
There are legitimate reasons prosecutors negotiate criminal sentences. Witness problems, evidentiary weaknesses, a defendant's criminal history, rehabilitation prospects, victim preferences, and the uncertainty of trial can all affect an outcome.
Some cases demand mercy. Others call for severe punishment. Two cases carrying the same charge may present very different facts.
But public confidence in the justice system depends on more than the legal availability of a particular sentence.
But public confidence in the justice system depends on more than the legal availability of a particular sentence.
It also depends on the ability to understand how consequential decisions are made.
The Question That Remains
There is no evidence in the documents reviewed for this report that White's sentence was the product of corruption, favoritism, or an unlawful agreement.
Nor can the public determine from those documents whether the result reflected compelling mitigating circumstances, the expressed wishes of Cody Reed's family, or some other consideration.
Nor can the public determine from those documents whether the result reflected compelling mitigating circumstances, the expressed wishes of Cody Reed's family, or some other consideration.
What the records do establish is significant enough.
A young man died. Another young man admitted criminal responsibility. The prosecutor agreed to a 20-year suspended sentence, and a judge imposed it.
Meanwhile, Reed's family faced the ordinary and devastating work of burying someone they loved. They sought help paying for a headstone while the criminal justice system negotiated the consequences of his death.
Those two facts do not establish that the sentence was unjust. They do demonstrate why the reasons for it matter.
Those two facts do not establish that the sentence was unjust. They do demonstrate why the reasons for it matter.
The Tulsa County District Attorney's Office has the authority to negotiate plea agreements. The courts have the responsibility to determine lawful sentences. The public has a legitimate interest in understanding both.
Why did the State agree that a first-degree manslaughter conviction for Cody Reed's death should result in no immediate incarceration?
There may be a good explanation.
The plea and judgment documents we reviewed do not provide one.
The plea and judgment documents we reviewed do not provide one.
And in a case where a 20-year-old lost his life, that is a question worth answering.
Endnotes and Sources
Rachel Myers, Help Cody Reed's Family with Headstone Costs, GoFundMe (Dec. 8, 2024), https://www.gofundme.com/f/help-cody-reeds-family-with-headstone-costs (identifying Reed's age, date of death, surviving family members, and the requested headstone expenses).
https://fox23.com/news/local/tulsa-man-charged-in-death-of-passenger-following-dui-crash
https://fox23.com/news/local/tulsa-man-charged-in-death-of-passenger-following-dui-crash
Plea of Guilty and Summary of Facts, State v. White, No. CF-2025-2062 (Okla. Dist. Ct. Tulsa Cnty. 2026) (court file; document reviewed during Sept. 23, 2026, research). Previously examined plea materials recorded White's factual admission concerning reckless driving, the approximately .06 blood alcohol concentration, and the absence of prior felony convictions. Available from the Tulsa County District Court Clerk.
State v. White, No. CF-2025-2062, Sentencing Minute Entry (Okla. Dist. Ct. Tulsa Cnty. May 18, 2026), reproduced in Kent Morlan, State of Oklahoma v. Jerrion Dawyne White, MoreLaw (May 18, 2026), https://www.morelaw.com/verdicts/cf-2025-2062/OK/200993/ (identifying counsel, guilty pleas, concurrent suspended sentences, and supervision conditions).
Judgment and Sentence, State v. White, No. CF-2025-2062 (Okla. Dist. Ct. Tulsa Cnty. May 18, 2026) (court file; previously reviewed).
Okla. Stat. tit. 22, §§ 991a(A)(1), 991b(A) (2025) (authorizing suspended sentences subject to statutory limitations and establishing procedures for revocation).
Okla. Stat. tit. 22, §§ 991a(A)(1), 991b(A) (2025) (authorizing suspended sentences subject to statutory limitations and establishing procedures for revocation).
Plea of Guilty and Prosecutor's Sentencing Recommendation, State v. White, No. CF-2025-2062 (Okla. Dist. Ct. Tulsa Cnty. 2026) (court file; previously reviewed).
Okla. Stat. tit. 21, § 711(1) (2026) (defining first-degree manslaughter, including homicide committed without a design to effect death during the commission of a misdemeanor). OSCN statutory text.
Okla. Stat. tit. 21, § 13.1 (2026) (including first-degree manslaughter among offenses subject to the statutory minimum-service requirement). OSCN statutory text.
Official case record: State v. Jerrion Dawyne White, CF-2025-2062, Tulsa County District Court. OSCN Tulsa County Docket Search. Search by the case number to locate the docket and available filings.
Official case record: State v. Jerrion Dawyne White, CF-2025-2062, Tulsa County District Court. OSCN Tulsa County Docket Search. Search by the case number to locate the docket and available filings.